This page was automatically translated from Dutch. In case of doubt, the Dutch version applies. View the Dutch version

Rugmedisch Centrum Fysiotherapie

Open now · until 15:00

From practice

Hernia: operate or not? When it is and is not necessary

Does a hernia always require surgery? Usually not. We explain when surgery is necessary, when waiting is wiser, and how our non-surgical hernia protocol works.

Knowledge baseBy Arthur Mulder ·

MRI image of the low back

A hernia — officially a hernia nuclei pulpos (HNP) — sounds like a diagnosis where the operating room is unavoidable. Yet the opposite applies to most hernias: with a structured, non-surgical approach, a large proportion of patients recover without surgery. In this article we explain when surgery is necessary, when waiting is wiser, and how our hernia protocol works.

On this page7
  1. What exactly is a hernia?
  2. Does a hernia always require surgery?
  3. The non-surgical hernia protocol
  4. When is surgery necessary? (alarm signals)
  5. How long does the recovery take?
  6. Is the treatment reimbursed?
  7. Frequently asked questions

What exactly is a hernia?

There are intervertebral discs between your vertebrae that act as shock absorbers. With a hernia, the soft core of such a disc bulges and presses on a nerve. This causes the well-known complaints: radiating pain in the leg or arm, tingling, a numb feeling or loss of strength. Most hernias occur in the low back (lumbar) or the neck (cervical).

Does a hernia always require surgery?

No. International guidelines advise first following a conservative (non-surgical) course for most herniated discs. The body has a great capacity to heal: bulging disc material can shrink on its own over weeks to months, reducing the pressure on the nerve. Surgery often relieves pain faster in the short term, but after one to two years the result of a good conservative course is in many cases comparable — without the risks of an operation.

The non-surgical hernia protocol

We combine several techniques in one structured programme. We don’t just treat the pain, but the cause: the pressure on the nerve.

  • Spinal decompression — targeted, gentle traction intended to reduce the pressure on the intervertebral disc and the nerve; it has not been proven that bulging material retracts as a result.
  • Gentle chiropractic care — restoring mobility and reducing compensatory tension, without heavy-handed cracking.
  • Targeted injection therapy — where necessary, to reduce inflammation around the nerve and speed recovery.
  • Exercise & posture advice — to stabilize the torso and prevent relapse.

Curious about the complete process? Read more about our hernia protocol or view the page about hernia as a complaint.

When is surgery necessary? (alarm signals)

There are situations in which you should not wait but need immediate medical attention:

  • Loss of bladder or bowel control.
  • A numb feeling around the buttocks or pubic area (saddle anesthesia).
  • Rapidly increasing, severe loss of strength in a leg or arm.

These signs may indicate cauda equina syndrome and require emergency care. In all other cases, a calm, focused conservative approach is usually the best first step.

How long does the recovery take?

Many patients notice a reduction in radiating pain within a few weeks. A complete process usually takes 6 to 12 weeks, depending on the severity and how long the complaints have existed. During the intake we draw up a personal plan with a realistic assessment for your situation.

Is the treatment reimbursed?

Most supplementary health insurance policies (partly) cover chiropractic. Easily check what your policy covers with our reimbursement checker. You do not need a referral from your GP to make an appointment.

Frequently asked questions

Is chiropractic safe for a hernia?

Yes, provided it is performed by an experienced, registered practitioner and with the correct technique. For hernias we use gentle techniques and decompression — no heavy-handed manipulations.

Can a hernia go away on its own?

Often yes. The bulging material can shrink over time. A targeted program supports and accelerates that natural recovery.

Should I keep moving or rest?

Prolonged bed rest is not recommended. Regular exercise — under supervision — promotes recovery.

Are you unsure whether surgery is necessary? First have your hernia assessed by our team. Often referred to Rotterdam within a week, no referral necessary. Schedule an appointment or call us.

This article is informational and does not replace personal medical advice. In case of doubt or persistent complaints, always consult a doctor or BIG-registered healthcare provider.

Sources

Independent information from Thuisarts.nl, the patient website of the Dutch College of General Practitioners (in Dutch).

More articles

Read more about your symptoms and what we do about them.

Responsible practitioner

Arthur Mulder

Physical Therapist and Registered Chiropractor (D.C.)

Registered in RegisterChiropractor (National Register of Chiropractors) as A.R. Mulder DC and affiliated with the Dutch Chiropractic Federation. Oversees chiropractic care in Rotterdam and is co-founder of SportManipulation, which provides training for physiotherapists and sports masseurs.

For injections: Dr. Björn Mulder, doctor of orthopaedic medicine.

Last updated on

Ready to get rid of your complaints?

No referral needed — make an appointment straight away.

What does your insurer reimburse?

Choose your insurer and your additional package. You will immediately see what chiropractic care is reimbursed.

Good to know

  • From the supplementary insurance, so not from your deductible.
  • No GP referral required.
  • You will receive an invoice with everything your insurer needs.

Source: chiropractievergoeding.nl, policy year 2026 (version 1.0 — 21-11-2025). This is an indication; your own policy always prevails.